Ice Cream

Warmer weather means it's time to hit the trail - the ice cream trail, that is!

Indianapolis has a number of parlors, pop-up shops, dairy bars, and drive-ins. So, ready your sweet tooth; this Indianapolis ice cream trail has it all.

tpc

The Dairy Bar at Traders Point Creamery

Searching for a homemade, hand-scooped dairy treat? Belly up to the Dairy Bar, which serves ice cream, milkshakes, smoothies, and sundaes made from organic, grass-fed milk and cream.

DeBrand

DeBrand Fine Chocolates

A chic and tranquil cafe offering a plethora of sweets, including ice cream, sundaes, fine chocolates, and hot chocolate. Nestled right in the heart of the Keystone Crossing area, DeBrand is the perfect way to indulge your sweet tooth on your day on the Northside.

gordons
Image: @christine_runs_indy
Credit: @christine_runs_indy

Gordon's Milkshake Bar

This milkshake shop on Mass Ave is truly one to add to your list. With craft shakes made from homemade ice cream, including dairy free and vegan options, Gordon’s Milkshakes are bound to excite your taste buds.

Wylie

Wyliepalooza Ice Cream Emporium

This Irvington-based ice cream shop is family-owned, with a second shop in SoBro. Between the two locations, there are nearly seven dozen flavors of super premium ice cream available.

Brics

Broad Ripple Ice Cream Station (BRICS)

BRICS is located in the original Broad Ripple train station. It has 24 permanent flavors, 12 rotating flavors, and is committed to being environmentally friendly. (Metal tasting spoons, anyone?)

lick

Lick Ice Cream

Artisanal ice cream? Yes, please. In 2010, two sisters teamed up to form Lick, which uses local fruit and organic waffle cones. Flavors include Balsamic Dark Chocolate, Mimosa, and Gingersnap Lemon Curd.

Mug N Bun

Mug N' Bun

Get your shake on. This west side icon has been serving milkshakes and malts for nearly 50 years. Also on the menu: floats, sundaes, and homemade root beer. Best of all, this drive-in won't break the bank.

sub zero

Sub Zero Ice Cream & Yogurt

Sub Zero - part of a Utah-based franchise - uses liquid nitrogen to instantly freeze a custom ice cream. Each serving is made fresh upon order, and takes only seconds to make.

Tiny House Treats

Satisfy your sweet tooth at this quaint parlor. Located just off the Monon Trail in SoBro, Tiny House Treats offers hand-dipped, soft serve ice cream, and even doggie sundaes for Fido.

Chris' Ice Cream

It's not a dream; at Chris' Ice Cream, ice cream and Mexican food are under one roof. The sweet treat is house-made and available in a number of flavors, including coconut and mango.

Chcolate Co

South Bend Chocolate Company

South Bend Chocolate Company, the fastest-growing chocolate company in the U.S., delights visitors with ice cream (and chocolates by the pound) from its store on Monument Circle.

nicey

Nicey Frozen Treats

These frozen treats are handmade and all-natural. Nicey - which has two pop-up shops and can be found at various farmers' markets - offers flavors such as strawberry mint and pink lemonade.

Handel's Homemade Ice Cream

Since1945 Handel's Homemade Ice Cream & Yogurt is made fresh every day on the premises. With multiple locations in Indy, each batch of homemade goodness is made in freezers specifically designed to create Handel's distinctively smooth and creamy texture.

Heartland Homemade Ice Cream

Beech Grove's Heartland creates fun flavors with many dairy-free options daily. You'll find old time favorites like mint chip and experiment tastes like cornbread. Also serving ice cream flights, soda floats, and freeze-dried candy.

Sundae's

With more than 30 years of experience in the ice cream industry, Sundae’s has mastered classic recipes and been able to innovate new flavors. This family-owned business still makes it the old-fashioned way, one batch at a time.

Bubs

Bub's Burgers & Ice Cream

Slurp down a milkshake at Bub's, a Carmel-based business with additional locations in Zionsville and Bloomington. Shakes and malts come in vanilla, chocolate, strawberry, and banana.

Goose the Market

Want to bring home literal bacon? Swing by Goose the Market, a market and butcher shop whose gelato (and outdoor seating) are perfect on a sunny day.

graeters

Graeter's

Graeter's is the only commercial ice cream manufacturer in the world to use French Pot freezers. Stop at one of their three stores in the Indianapolis area.

The Mug

The Mug

The Mug - located in Greenfield - specializes in "farm-to-curb" fare. The menu at this non-traditional drive-in includes soft serve, as well as single- and double-scoop cones.

You Might Also Like:

Donuts
Start your day off right with one of our favorite dessert-for-breakfast spots.
Learn More
Food Halls
You’ve been craving tacos all day, but your husband wants a burger, and the kids will throw a fit if they…
Learn More
Vegan & Vegetarian
No matter if you've put your carnivore ways on the shelf, or just prefer restaurants with lighter eating options, here are…
Learn More
Pizza
Indy's pizza game is strong. October may be National Pizza Month, but any day is perfect for a slice.
Learn More