Mama Carolla's Old Italian Restaurant

1031 E. 54th St
Indianapolis, IN 46220
317-259-9412
VIEW WEBSITE

Broad Ripple

HOURS

Check website for hours

COST

$12 to $24

Open For Business


Overall Average Rating: 4.5 (780 reviews)


Karen R.
09/03/2022

Service was pretty non existent. Took forever to take our drink order & it didn't come until after our appetizers. Always liked this place but food was...


Sophie O.
08/05/2022

- Fried Ravioli 6.8/10 literally wasn't even hot. So disappointed - Calamari 9/10 this sauce is fire. Calamari is not chewy at all. I think it is the best...


Sheree W.
09/24/2022

I have lived in Indpls my entire life and have always wanted to try this place but honestly never made a serious effort, until now that is. Came here on a...



RELATED GUIDES

Indy's Top 25 Local Restaurants

We polled local residents to vote on their favorite restaurants to help visitors plan their culinary adventure with the city's best bites.