Due to COVID 19, we encourage you to check the status of any Indianapolis establishment prior to visiting.

Mama Carolla's Old Italian Restaurant

(610 reviews)

1031 E. 54th St
Indianapolis, IN 46220

(get directions)

317-259-9412
VIEW WEBSITE

Broad Ripple

COST

$12 to $24

Nestled in a 1920s stucco-style home, Mama Carolla’s has become an Indy staple for their intimate atmosphere and romantic outdoor terrace. This South Broad Ripple family-run restaurant is known for homemade meatballs and steamed mussels, both favorites among the loyal locals.